Cartiva Big Toe Implant Lawsuit December 2023 Update

The Cartiva Implant Lawsuit is a legal dispute that raises substantial concerns about the effectiveness and safety of the Cartiva Synthetic Cartilage Implant. This medical device, intended to alleviate the symptoms of arthritis in the big toe, has instead been linked with a high failure rate and severe complications, leading to considerable suffering for patients.

Arthritis in the big toe, or hallux rigidus, is a painful condition that affects over 2.2 million Americans. This degenerative form of arthritis erodes the cartilage in the first joint of the big toe, resulting in severe pain and limited range of motion. Prior to the introduction of the Cartiva Implant in 2015, the primary treatment for this condition was a surgical procedure known as big toe fusion, or arthrodesis. However, the fusion surgery came with its own set of challenges, including a long recovery period and potential loss of joint mobility.

The Cartiva Implant, a small cylindrical device made of a gel-like polyvinyl alcohol-based hydrogel (PVA), promised a revolutionary alternative. This implant was designed to replace the degraded cartilage in the joint, acting as a cushion to prevent painful bone-on-bone friction. It was marketed as a safe and effective solution, offering patients a less invasive option with quicker recovery times.

However, the reality of the Cartiva Implant was far from this promise. Patients began reporting a wide range of serious complications, including severe pain, loosening or fracturing of the implant, and subsidence, a condition where the implant sinks into the bone. These complications often necessitated additional surgeries, leading to more pain and suffering for patients.

The Cartiva Implant Lawsuit alleges that the manufacturers of this device, including Cartiva Inc., Wright Medical Group, and Stryker, were aware of these issues but chose to withhold this information from both the medical community and patients. The lawsuits claim that the manufacturers were more interested in avoiding a product recall and protecting their profits than ensuring patient safety.

Now, victims of Cartiva implant failures are seeking justice and compensation for their suffering. If you or a loved one has been affected, understanding the Cartiva Implant Lawsuit is the first step towards claiming your rights.

It's crucial to understand that you are not alone in this journey - ConsumerShield is here to guide you through the process. We connect you with skilled lawyers who specialize in class action lawsuit claims, ensuring that your case is in the right hands. Our mission is to provide more than just connections; we aim to be a supportive partner in your pursuit of justice.

Apply for Cartiva Implant Lawsuit now!

By submitting, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.


Lawsuits shown in:
CBS CNN FOX New York Times

Stay up to date

Get updates on all of our lawsuits, news, articles, research and lawsuit updates.

What Is the Cartiva Implant?

Cartiva Implant Lawsuit
Cartiva Implant Lawsuit

The Cartiva Implant is a medical device designed to alleviate the discomfort and motion limitations caused by arthritis in the big toe, a condition that affects over 2.2 million people in the United States. The device was introduced to the medical community in 2015, offering what seemed like a promising alternative to the traditional, more invasive big toe fusion surgery, also known as arthrodesis.

The Cartiva Implant is a small, cylindrical device made of polyvinyl alcohol-based hydrogel (PVA). This unique material was chosen for its ability to mimic the properties of natural cartilage, a soft tissue that cushions the ends of bones at the joints, preventing them from rubbing against each other. In patients with arthritis, cartilage degradation occurs, leading to painful bone-on-bone contact.

The purpose of the Cartiva Implant is to act as an artificial replacement for the degraded cartilage. It's designed to fit neatly into the big toe joint, providing a gel-like cushion that reduces pain and restores a degree of normal joint function.

The implant procedure involves the creation of a cavity in the metatarsal head, the round part of the bone located at the base of the big toe. The Cartiva Implant is then inserted into this cavity, with the aim of providing relief without the need for removing a significant amount of healthy tissue or causing extensive surgical trauma.

The Cartiva Implant's promise of minimal surgical trauma, combined with a quicker recovery time compared to traditional surgery, initially made it an attractive option for many patients. However, in practice, the implant has been linked to a high rate of failure and a host of serious complications, which has led to legal action against its manufacturers.

How the Cartiva Implant Works

The Cartiva Implant was designed as a revolutionary solution for patients suffering from hallux limitus or hallux rigidus, forms of degenerative arthritis that affect the first metatarsophalangeal joint, or the first joint of the big toe. This joint is crucial to our ability to walk, run, and jump effectively and without pain. The degradation of cartilage in this joint, a common consequence of these conditions, can lead to significant discomfort and decreased range of motion.

The Cartiva Implant, made of a polyvinyl alcohol-based hydrogel (PVA), is a small cylindrical device designed to replace the degraded cartilage in the joint. The PVA material is chosen for its unique properties that closely mimic the nature of natural cartilage, providing cushioning between the bones and reducing friction.

The implantation procedure involves a surgeon creating a cavity in the metatarsal head, which is the round, upper part of the bone at the base of the big toe. The size of the cavity is carefully tailored to match the size of the Cartiva Implant. Using specialized instrumentation, the surgeon then inserts the Cartiva Implant into the cavity.

Once implanted, the Cartiva device is meant to behave much like natural cartilage, acting as a buffer between the bones in the joint. This is intended to alleviate the bone-on-bone rubbing and the associated pain, restoring a degree of normal joint function and mobility to the patient.

Unlike big toe fusion surgery, which often results in the loss of joint mobility, the Cartiva Implant is designed to preserve joint motion and function. It also promised minimal surgical trauma and a quick recovery time, making it an initially appealing option for many patients.

However, despite its innovative design and promising initial claims, the Cartiva Implant has been associated with a high rate of failure and severe complications. This discrepancy between the promise and the reality of the Cartiva Implant has led to a surge in legal actions against its manufacturers.

What Types of Complications are Being Reported in the Cartiva Implant Lawsuit?

The Cartiva Implant Lawsuit has brought to light a multitude of serious complications that patients have experienced following the implantation of the Cartiva device. Despite the initial promise of the implant as a revolutionary solution for big toe arthritis, the reality has proven far less rosy for many patients.

One of the most common complications reported is severe and persistent toe pain, which not only limits the mobility of patients but also significantly impacts their quality of life. This pain is often a result of the implant loosening within the joint or fracturing, both of which can cause the joint to fail.

Subsidence, a condition in which the implant sinks into the bone, has also been frequently reported. This can result in further pain and necessitate additional surgeries to correct the issue.

More worryingly, some patients have reported nerve damage and debilitating pain due to the Cartiva implant shrinking once implanted. This shrinkage can cause the implant to migrate from its original position, leading to serious complications.

Additional complications reported in the lawsuit include infections, implant fracture, osteolysis (the destruction or disappearance of bone tissue), bone over-production, cysts, and silastic granulomas. These complications often necessitate further surgeries, increasing the patient's suffering, medical costs, and recovery time.

At ConsumerShield, we believe that patients deserve justice and compensation for these complications. We meticulously connect individuals with our network of skilled lawyers, handpicked for their expertise in class action lawsuit claims like the Cartiva Implant Lawsuit. Our commitment goes beyond just making connections. We provide a partnership in your journey towards justice, offering guidance and support every step of the way.

Several studies that have raised concerns about the Cartiva implant's efficacy and safety:

  • November 2022 Study: Preliminary findings of an ongoing study published in a medical journal found that patients who received the Cartiva toe implant reported more post-operative pain. The study reviewed 50 patients who underwent Cartiva hemiarthroplasty, arthrodesis (fusion of the joint), or interpositional arthroplasty. It found that Cartiva patients reported a worse overall combination of postoperative pain, function, and alignment compared to patients who received the alternative treatments.
  • October 2020 Study: A study published by the American Orthopedic Foot and Ankle Society indicated a high failure risk for patients receiving Cartiva implants for the treatment of hallux rigidus. Within two years of receiving the implant, there was a 79% implant failure risk. Furthermore, 64% of patients who received a Cartiva implant experienced device failure within four weeks of the surgery. The most commonly reported reason for Cartiva failure was subsidence, where the implant loosened and sank into the toe bone, resulting in severe toe pain and revision surgery in some cases.
  • October 2019 Study: Researchers from Cedar Sinai Hospital found that 30% of Cartiva Synthetic Cartilage Implant (SCI) recipients were either dissatisfied or very dissatisfied with the outcomes of the procedure. The study found 50% required a corticosteroid injection after receiving the implant. The researchers concluded that the Cartiva implant only yielded modest patient satisfaction, with a large proportion requiring further treatment and workup postoperatively.

If you or a loved one has experienced any of these complications following the implantation of the Cartiva device, reach out to ConsumerShield. We're here to help you understand your rights and to support you in your claim for compensation. You do not have to navigate this complex legal landscape alone. With ConsumerShield, you have a partner committed to helping you seek the justice you deserve.

What Is the Status of the Cartiva Implant Lawsuits? Latest Updates in Cartiva Implant Lawsuits 2023

As of 2023, the Cartiva Implant Lawsuits have started to gain significant traction, with a growing number of affected patients and their families seeking legal recourse. The central allegations of these lawsuits are that Cartiva Inc., Wright Medical Group, and Stryker, the manufacturers and distributors of the Cartiva Implant, were aware of the high failure rate and potential complications of the device, but withheld this critical information to avoid a product recall and protect their profits.

These lawsuits claim that the manufacturers failed in their duty to ensure the safety and effectiveness of their product, leading to widespread patient suffering. The victims are now seeking justice and compensation for their pain, suffering, medical expenses, and loss of income resulting from additional surgeries and recovery periods.

In addition to individual lawsuits, there is a growing momentum towards forming a class-action lawsuit. A class-action lawsuit allows a group of people who have suffered similar harm to join together to sue the responsible party. This approach can be particularly effective when the damages for each individual may not be substantial enough to justify the costs of individual lawsuits.

While no settlements have been announced as of mid-2023, the increasing number of lawsuits suggests that the manufacturers could face significant financial penalties. Given the severity of the complications reported and the alleged concealment of these risks by the manufacturers, it is plausible that any eventual settlement or judgment could result in substantial compensation for the victims.

The situation continues to evolve rapidly, and staying informed about the latest developments is crucial for those affected. ConsumerShield is committed to keeping you updated and providing expert guidance throughout this process. We understand the complexity of such lawsuits and the immense physical and emotional strain they can place on victims and their families. That's why we're dedicated to connecting you with skilled lawyers who can effectively represent your interests and help you navigate this challenging journey. With ConsumerShield, you're not alone in your fight for justice.


We are working with thousands of amazing partners.

“Never imagined that understanding complex legal issues could be so easy. The Consumer Shield demystified everything for me.”

Roundup Lawsuit Participant

“As someone who was completely new to the world of lawsuits, The Consumer Shield provided the perfect starting point and direction.”

Roundup Lawsuit Participant

“Drowning in legalities, The Consumer Shield was the lifeline I didn't know I needed. Now, I'm well-informed and ready to take action.”

Aware Individual

“Feeling lost and uninformed, The Consumer Shield was a beacon of information. I finally understood my rights and potential legal actions.”

Family Member of a talcum powder victim

“Navigating potential lawsuits felt daunting, but The Consumer Shield provided the clarity and information I desperately needed.”

Tylenol Lawsuit Participant

“Legal processes always seemed foreign and intimidating. Thanks to The Consumer Shield, I feel like I've taken a masterclass in understanding my rights.”

Paraquat Lawsuit Participant

Potential Settlement Compensation Payout in the Cartiva Implant Lawsuits

The potential settlement compensation payout in the Cartiva Implant Lawsuits is currently unknown as no settlements have been announced as of 2022. However, it's important to note that each case is unique and the potential settlement or court-awarded compensation will depend on the specific circumstances of each individual claim.

In legal cases such as this, several factors are considered when determining the compensation amount. These can include the severity of complications experienced, the degree of pain and suffering endured, the cost of past and future medical expenses related to the implant failure, loss of income due to time off work for recovery, and the impact of the complications on the individual's quality of life.

For instance, a patient who experienced severe complications leading to multiple additional surgeries and a prolonged period off work would likely be eligible for a higher amount of compensation than someone who had a less severe experience. This is because they have endured more pain and suffering, incurred higher medical costs, and potentially lost more income.

It's also important to consider that if the allegations of the lawsuits are proven - that the manufacturers knowingly sold a defective product and failed to adequately warn doctors and patients about the potential risks - this could potentially influence the compensation amounts. In some cases, punitive damages may also be awarded as a form of punishment for particularly egregious behavior on the part of the defendants and as a deterrent for others.

At ConsumerShield, we understand that no amount of money can truly compensate for the pain and suffering caused by the Cartiva implant failures. However, achieving a successful claim can provide some level of financial relief and a sense of justice for those affected.

Our role at ConsumerShield is to connect you with legal professionals who have the expertise to accurately value your claim and to fight for the compensation you deserve. With ConsumerShield, you can feel confident that your claim is being handled by a skilled and experienced team who understand the complexities of the Cartiva Implant Lawsuits and are dedicated to achieving the best possible outcome for you. Don't navigate this complex process alone - let ConsumerShield be your trusted partner in your journey towards justice.

Do I Qualify to File a Cartiva Lawsuit?

Taking the first step towards filing a Cartiva implant lawsuit can feel daunting, especially when you're already dealing with the physical and emotional stress of the implant failure. However, with the right support, the process can be straightforward, and justice can be within your reach.

If you or a loved one have experienced complications after receiving a Cartiva toe implant, such as persistent pain, loosening or fracturing of the implant, subsidence, or other severe issues leading to further surgeries, you may qualify to file a Cartiva lawsuit. Here's a step-by-step guide on how to get started with ConsumerShield:

  • Step 1: Complete the Form Start by completing the form on the ConsumerShield website. This form will ask for initial information about your case, such as the nature of the complications you've experienced, any additional treatments you've had to undergo, and how these complications have impacted your life. Once you've submitted the form, our intake support team or a representative from our associated law firm will get in touch within hours to begin the process.
  • Step 2: Free Claim Review Following your initial contact, our team will conduct a free claim review. During this review, we'll gather detailed information about your situation to evaluate your potential claim's strength and value. We aim to answer all your questions and will explain the process in detail so that you know what to expect. This case review is crucial in determining whether you qualify to file a Cartiva lawsuit.
  • Step 3: Get Justice Once we've collected all necessary information and confirmed that you qualify to file a lawsuit, you'll receive support from our network of experienced attorneys and medical experts. These professionals have helped secure millions in damages for people just like you, and they'll put that expertise to work on your behalf. They will handle the legal complexities, allowing you to focus on your health and well-being.

Frequently Asked Questions

  • Eligibility to participate in the Cartiva Implant Lawsuit is typically determined on a case-by-case basis. However, generally, you may be eligible if you or a loved one have had a Cartiva implant and subsequently experienced complications such as persistent pain, loosening or fracturing of the implant, subsidence, or other issues that necessitated additional surgeries. To find out if you qualify, it's best to consult with a legal professional. ConsumerShield can connect you with experienced attorneys who can evaluate your situation and determine your eligibility.

  • As of my knowledge cut-off in September 2021, specific failure rate statistics for the Cartiva implant have not been officially published or verified. However, numerous patient reports and lawsuits suggest that the failure rate may be higher than initially expected. It's recommended to consult with your medical provider or a legal professional for the most recent and accurate information.

  • To join the Cartiva Implant Lawsuit, start by reaching out to a legal professional who specializes in such cases. At ConsumerShield, we can connect you with experienced attorneys who can evaluate your case, determine your eligibility, and guide you through the process of joining the lawsuit.

  • The potential compensation from the Cartiva Implant Lawsuit can vary widely depending on the specifics of your case. Factors such as the severity of your complications, the cost of your medical treatment, the impact on your ability to work, and the degree of pain and suffering you've endured can all affect the potential compensation. Legal professionals can provide an estimate based on these factors.

  • As of my knowledge cut-off in September 2021, the Cartiva implant was still being used. However, given the ongoing lawsuits and reported complications, the status may have changed. Please consult with a healthcare provider or legal professional for the most recent information.

  • The longevity of the Cartiva implant can vary from patient to patient. It depends on several factors, including the patient's overall health, activity level, and how well the body accepts the implant. However, numerous reports of early failure have surfaced, prompting lawsuits against the manufacturer.

  • The problem with the Cartiva implant, as alleged in numerous lawsuits, is a higher-than-expected failure rate leading to severe complications such as persistent pain, loosening or fracturing of the implant, subsidence (where the implant sinks into the bone), and other issues that necessitate additional surgeries.

  • Symptoms of Cartiva implant failure can include persistent and severe toe pain, swelling, limited mobility in the toe or foot, changes in the way you walk, and the feeling of instability in the joint. If you're experiencing these symptoms after receiving a Cartiva implant, it's important to consult with a healthcare provider immediately.

The Consumer Shield is Here to Help You

At ConsumerShield, we're not just a service, but a partner in your journey towards justice. We understand the physical, emotional, and financial burdens that a failed Cartiva implant can impose, and we're dedicated to helping you navigate this challenging time.

By connecting you with skilled legal professionals and providing ongoing support, we aim to make the pursuit of your Cartiva implant lawsuit as stress-free as possible. Let ConsumerShield be your trusted ally in your fight for justice.

Apply for Cartiva Implant Lawsuit now!

By submitting, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.

Other Defective Product Lawsuits

Stay up to date

Get updates on all of our lawsuits, news, articles, research and lawsuit updates.

Our goals

Efficient Legal Process: Streamline Your Case

Experience a streamlined and timely legal process that ensures your lawsuit stays on track and progresses efficiently.

Maximize Your Compensation: Our Dedicated Advocacy

Our relentless advocacy is focused on securing the highest possible compensation for individuals impacted.

People-Centric Approach: Your Interests Come First

Count on our unwavering commitment to prioritize what's best for people affected, ensuring their rights and interests are safeguarded.